SAGINAW, Mich. (Michigan Back Roads) – The Great Lakes have claimed hundreds, perhaps thousands, of vessels large and small. Some became famous like the Edmund Fitzgerald taken by Lake Superior. Others became enduring mysteries like the fabled Griffin lost on her maiden voyage of exploration in August 1679. Some were no more than a skiff that went missing. Others live on as ghost ships of legend and lore.

The Schooner Ella Ellinwood was a working vessel, a three masted schooner built in 1869 in Saginaw, Michigan. She was kept busy transporting timber products and saw service transporting lumber from White Lake to Chicago, and other destinations, after the Chicago fire. Her destruction on Lake Michigan would have been just another shipwreck except for the odd incident that occurred a year later.

MORE NEWS: Train Crash Kills One in Kalamazoo

There were no omens or portents that the run to Wisconsin on that fateful day would be the final voyage of the Ellinwood. The schooner had a history of success with only an occasional mishap.  Documented troubles include a lost jib in a collision with a tug at Chicago, October 14, 1873; and the time she ran aground at White Lake in October 1874.

There was no hint of a jinx or an unlucky cloud hanging over the ship and it was a routine trip, just 85 miles or so from White Lake to Milwaukee. On September 29, 1901, Captain Thomas Flagstad took her out with a 150-ton cargo of bark, bound for Milwaukee. The schooner was within sight of Wisconsin when a combination of smoke and stormy mist hid the shoreline from view. She ran aground on rocks near Fox Point a few miles north of Milwaukee. In the early morning hours, the captain and crew abandoned ship and made for safety. Though their yawl was overturned in the heavy waves, all hands made it to shore.

Lake Michigan continued to storm through the night. It wasn’t until the next morning that the men could attempt to run lines out and try to get her afloat. The effort was to no avail. The waves continued to punish the Ellinwood until her hull was pounded to pieces. The schooner and her entire cargo were a complete loss. Though there was nothing of the Ellinwood left to salvage, no lives had been lost.

The matter would have disappeared into the past and been forgotten except for a strange twist of fate. The following year a ship’s nameplate “ELLINWOOD” washed up on the shore of White Lake, where the disastrous voyage had begun. Somehow the nameplate had drifted across Lake Michigan and made it into its’ home port of White Lake. That nameplate is on display at City Hall in Montague, Michigan.

The Montague City Hall is on the north edge of downtown. They operate a small museum in the basement. That is where the nameplate is displayed along with a complete history of the Ellinwood. When you first arrive in town you will see a gigantic weathervane. It is the largest weathervane in the world. t he ship atop the main pole depicts the schooner, Ella Ellinwood.

MORE NEWS: Bus Service Adds More Stops Between Detroit and Mt. Pleasant

* Last Document of Enrollment Surrendered: Grand Haven: 12/19/1901: “Vessel Lost”.